Now or Then

Six grocery products are shown on a circular board, each with a price shown. The contestant chooses a product, one at a time, and must guess if the given price is correct as of “NOW” (the date the game is being played) or “THEN” (a date set years in the past)

A correct answer lights up a “wedge”, while a wrong answer blocks the contestant’s progress. If the contestant can light up three adjacent “wedges” in a row, they win a large prize!

Now or Then is one of the most unique tests of knowledge offered in a pricing game. Initially “THEN” prices were found using old newspapers; they’re now determined with old episodes of The Price is Right!

47th pricing game to debut
S9, September 17 1980 – Present
Created by Steve Ryan
S9, Sep 17 1980

Theresa’s playing for a dining room group with flatware & glassware, worth $2,293!

When the game debuted, it was under the name “Now and Then”.

For gameplay purposes, “NOW” is “today” (1980), and “THEN” is April 1977.

Each of the six products here existed in 1977… Theresa’s job will be to determine whether each listed price is “NOW” or “THEN”.

Fortunately, she doesn’t need to get them all right. She just needs to get three adjoining spaces on the game board to win.

Theresa chooses the Powerhouse candy bar for her first pick. Is 25¢ the price of the candy “NOW”, or “THEN”?

A Price is Right contestant, looking surprised, speaks to the host while holding a microphone, with a colorful background.

Theresa confidently says that it’s NOW!

And she’s right!

In fact, she wins her second pick, too, with the Cortaid itch cream. Getting either the Borateem or the gum will form three in a row…

A package of Borateem laundry detergent displayed on an orange background, with a price tag showing 95¢.

She isn’t sure about either… but she decides to go with the Borateem.

The audience is screaming “THEN”, and she follows them…

…she’s right!

A contestant on a game show with a big smile, showcasing excitement or enthusiasm.

The first Now and Then player, and she won in a clean sweep!

S13, Oct 25 1984

Eddie has the two leftmost wedges (they’re lit up), but missed the bottom wedge. He’ll have to get the Potato Buds at the top in order to win.

Eddie says the potato buds at $1.59 are “NOW”…

A contestant stands beside a circular game board labeled 'Now and Then', featuring prices for grocery products. The host gestures towards the board while the contestant appears to be engaged in gameplay.

…nope. Unfortunately, there aren’t enough spaces left to make three in a row.

S15, Dec 2 1986

After six years, the name changed from “Now and Then” to “Now or Then”, to better reflect the choice being asked of the contestant.

S18, Sep 19 1989

You may think in 1989 it would still cost $2.19 for a jar of raisins…

A colorful sign displaying 'jan. 1984' in bold letters, with lights surrounding it and a product labeled 'Handi-Wipes' partially visible below.

But you’d be wrong. This is literally just like 1984!

Who controls the past, controls the future… and who controls the raisins, wins a spa!

S26, Feb 13 1998

Contestants weren’t required to pick items in any order, and could bounce around the board as they pleased.

S35, May 31 2007
A contestant and host stand beside a colorful game board featuring a circular spinner divided into sections labeled 'NOW or THEN'. The board displays various grocery products with their prices.

By the time of Bob’s final playing, “THEN” could be as much as 10 years in the past.

A “hidden rule” was also put in place. Each game ALWAYS had four “NOW” prices and two “THEN” prices.

S37, Apr 13 2009

Speaking of throwbacks to the past, take a look at this prize… remember when Netflix mailed you DVDs?

S38, Feb 17 2010

Bouncing around wasn’t always the best strategy.

After missing with the oven cleaner, Eileen went to the exact opposite side and tried the toothpaste, guessing $1.91 was “NOW”.

Unfortunately, it wasn’t…

…and Eileen locked herself out of a win after trying just two products.

Slate, “Winning the Price is Right”

Bouncing around can be helpful, however. As long as you know there are always four NOWs and two THENs, Ben Blatt even figured out a way to GUARANTEE a win without knowing any prices.

S44, Sep 22 2015

For a Decades Week throwback to the 1980s, the game briefly returned to its original title.

S40, June 7 2012

One long-enduring urban legend held that any product with “NEW” on its packaging had to be “NOW”, believing that it couldn’t have been around in the past…

S42, Jun 27 2014

…this was true sometimes, but it was not always the case.

S47, April 2 2019

The board got some minor touch-ups around 2016.

S51, Feb 1 2023 (Primetime)

If Jacob can give a correct answer for these cheese wheels, he’ll not only win a $49,000 trailer in a clean sweep win, but he’ll also secure The Price is Right’s first ever perfect hourlong show in primetime…

“The cheese? THE CHEESE IS NOW!”

Indeed it is! And “THE CHEESE IS NOW” became the name of CBS’ newest soap opera. Since the show was going so perfectly, Drew had Jacob guess the other three just for fun.

S52, Feb 21 2024

Alison has also won an $11,000 living room in a clean sweep, so Drew sweetens the pot with a special primetime bonus…

…if she can nail the other three, she’ll also win maid service for 5 years!